In 1908 the emperor died at 38. The Empress Dowager died the next day. Coincidence? 《神州大地》第 10 集 · 語言:English · 時長:36:43 出處:sylogs.com — 歡迎轉載分享,請注明出處 November 14, 1908. Evening. Zhongnanhai, Beijing. On an island ringed by water, in a hall called Hanyuan, an emperor who had been held there for ten years died. He was thirty-eight. The next afternoon, the woman who had kept him there died too. The two deaths came less than a day apart. An emperor who reigned thirty-four years but held real power for none of his last ten, and a dowager empress who had held it for him for forty-seven years — dead in the same city, less than a day apart. That fact alone left a question that is still unsettled. This episode is about how a court goes about replacing its top man — and why, in the end, it could not. Start with where he lived. Inside Zhongnanhai there is a stretch of water called the South Lake, and in the middle of it an island called Yingtai. In the Ming it was called Nantai; it was renamed Yingtai under the Shunzhi emperor. Its main hall is Hanyuan Hall — and that is where Guangxu spent his last ten years. One thing needs to be clear: this was not imprisonment in a legal sense. He was still the emperor. The rites — sacrifice to Heaven, to the ancestors, the promulgation of the calendar were still nominally his. In court documents he was still "the Sovereign. " But everything that actually governed ran the other way: memorials went to the empress dowager first; appointments and dismissals were decided by her; money moved through her hands. What the emperor saw were mostly papers already decided, waiting for his formality. How did he pass his days? Yingtai is surrounded by water, with a single bridge in and out. When the lake froze in winter, eunuchs crossed on the ice to deliver things. He read and wrote in Hanyuan Hall, and each morning put down a few lines of exercise — the habit Qing princes were raised with. The medical records kept by the Imperial Hospital list his complaints: insomnia, ringing in the ears, back pain, poor appetite, and a long-standing condition that never healed. The prescriptions changed, one after another, for ten years. People at the time had a phrase for it: "an emperor in name, a bird in a cage. " He had a second residence: Yulantang, inside the Summer Palace. The Summer Palace stands in Haidian. It began as the Garden of Clear Ripples under Qianlong, was burned by the Anglo-French forces in 1860, and was rebuilt after 1888 nominally with naval funds — and renamed Yiheyuan. In her later years Cixi spent more days here than in the palace: she lived in Leshou Hall and heard business in Renshou Hall. Guangxu came here too. After the 1898 coup, he was kept in Yulantang. It is recorded that the rear gate of Yulantang leading outward was bricked up, and the passage to the adjacent Yiyun Lodge was cut off which doors he entered and left by were all arranged for him. The Summer Palace is open to visitors today, and that bricked-up doorway is still there. It is the first thing in this episode you can still go and see with your own eyes. An emperor kept under guard — why not simply depose him and put in someone else? The court actually tried. The date was early 1900. On the 24th day of the 12th month, Guangxu 25 — January 24, 1900 — Cixi issued an edict in the emperor's name making Pu Jun, son of Prince Duan (Zaiyi), the " First Prince" (da age). " " First Prince" is how an imperial son is addressed. A boy of fifteen was brought into the palace and placed beside the emperor to study. It is also recorded that the court drafted a new reign name, " Baoqing, " and intended to retire Guangxu as emperor emeritus — they had even settled on the new era name. But establishing an heir was too large a thing to do quietly. The Zongli Yamen later had to explain to the foreign legations in Beijing that the court had no intention of deposing anyone. A replacement planned for a full year, with a new reign name already drafted, never went through. The key is hidden in the title. What they installed was not a "crown prince. " It was a " First Prince. " The man handling it was Grand Secretary Ronglu. He put it this way: Pu Jun was "heir to the reigning sovereign, and also adopted to continue the line of Muzong. " The boy was nominally made a son of the reigning emperor, while also carrying the succession of the late Tongzhi emperor. Why the detour? Because changing the title changes the nature of the act. Installing a "crown prince" concedes that the present emperor is to step aside. Installing a " First Prince" to continue Tongzhi's line says instead: this supplies a descendant to a previous emperor and Guangxu's title stays intact. Cixi wanted him replaced, but did not want to carry the two words "deposed emperor. " This was a problem she had to work around. On January 27, 1900 — three days after the edict a group in Shanghai stood up. The leader was Jing Yuanshan, director of the Shanghai Telegraph Office. He joined with 1,231 others in a public telegram asking the emperor to "attend to government despite illness, and abandon all thought of abdication. " The list of signatories included Zhang Binglin, Cai Yuanpei, Huang Yanpei and Tang Caichang. This was not a few men sending up a memorial. It was a public telegram — the fastest, most public channel available then, the equivalent of an open letter. A single telegram sent from Shanghai could be reprinted by newspapers across the country. One Shanghai official, with more than a thousand names behind him, publicly opposing the court's intention to change emperors. And then? Then nothing. After the telegram, Cixi ordered Jing Yuanshan's arrest. He left Shanghai and eventually made his way to Macao. The replacement itself did not end there either. Zaiyi and his son Pu Jun were later named by the foreign powers as among the instigators of the 1900 crisis and exiled to Xinjiang. The title of " First Prince" was not formally abolished until 1901. The 1,231 names did not change any decision made that day. In this episode, they are the only group who spoke publicly on behalf of the man who was being held. That same year something larger happened. In the summer of 1900 the Boxers entered Beijing. They burned churches and killed converts, tore up railway track and cut telegraph poles. The court's position changed almost daily: first suppress them, then support them. On June 21 the court declared war on the foreign powers in the emperor's name. On August 14 the Eight-Nation Alliance fought its way into Beijing. Before dawn the next day, Cixi left the palace through the Gate of Divine Prowess, taking Guangxu, the empress and a few eunuchs and maids. She took off her Manchu robes, put on a blue cotton jacket, and dressed her hair in a Han style — disguised as an old woman from the countryside. She was gone more than a year. They went west: Juyong Pass, Xuanhua, Datong, Taiyuan, and finally Xi'an. Over seventy days, more than two thousand li. There were no imperial kitchens on the road; they ate coarse grain. At Huailai in Hebei a local person brought out a bowl of mung-bean porridge, and someone in the party wrote the scene down. In September 1901 the treaty was signed. In January 1902 she returned to Beijing. The emperor went out with her. The emperor came back with her. On the day she left the palace, she did not take Consort Zhen. Zhen was of the Tatara clan, of the Manchu Bordered Red Banner, born in 1876. In 1889, at thirteen, she entered the palace together with her elder sister, and was later given the rank of Consort Zhen. She could write and paint, and was bolder than most consorts when the palace said a camera would steal a person's soul, she insisted on being photographed. In 1894 she was demoted for selling offices. A man named Lu Boyang had bought his way into the post of Shanghai daotai; another, Yu Ming, who could barely read, obtained a salt administration post in Sichuan. When the case was investigated, it reached Consort Zhen and the eunuchs around her. After 1898 she was confined in the Beisansuo, north of the Palace of Tranquil Longevity. The door was locked from the outside and food was passed in through a window opening. Two years later, on that morning, Cixi was about to leave. It is recorded that she had Consort Zhen brought out, and that in the end Zhen was pushed into the well behind the Palace of Tranquil Longevity. She was twenty-four. There are two accounts. One says Zhen asked that the emperor be left in Beijing to handle the situation, which angered Cixi. The other says Cixi simply gave the order, on the ground that she could not be taken along. Both are recorded; this episode does not choose between them. After reaching Xi'an, Cixi issued an edict saying Zhen had drowned herself "to preserve her honor, " and posthumously raised her to Noble Consort Zhen. In 1913 her coffin was moved to the consorts' tombs beside the Chongling mausoleum. The well visitors walk past in the Palace Museum today is called the Well of Consort Zhen. To talk about Cixi's forty-seven years, one man cannot be passed over: the eunuch Li Lianying. He was born in 1848 in Dacheng county, Hejian prefecture, in Zhili, into a poor family; his father dealt in hides. He was castrated at six, first entered the household of Prince Zheng, and came into the Forbidden City in 1856. His birth name was Li Yingtai; in the palace he was called Li Jinxi; the name " Lianying" was given him by Cixi. His real rise came in 1869. That year the chief eunuch beside Cixi, An Dehai, left the palace on imperial business and traveled south. In Shandong he was arrested by Governor Ding Baozhen and executed on the spot. With An Dehai gone, Li Lianying took his place. From then on he stayed at Cixi's side for nearly forty years, until she died. Cixi did one thing that broke the rules: she gave Li Lianying the rank and peacock feather of a second-grade official. Qing eunuchs had a ceiling on rank, and after the Yongzheng emperor an iron tablet expressly forbade eunuchs from involving themselves in government. Giving a eunuch second-grade insignia broke the precedent. What was he like day to day? The contemporary record runs in two directions. On one side: cautious and careful, often speaking up for palace servants, and sometimes putting in a good word for the neglected emperor in the palace he was called "respectful and prudent. " It is said that even after being granted the second-grade insignia he did not dare wear it. On the other side, he took money. Officials competed to cultivate him, and a good number of houses stood in his name. Two things are remembered more clearly. One comes from the flight in 1900: a member of the party recalled that the night was cold and bedding short, and Li Lianying took his own bedding to the emperor and sat up all night wrapped in his clothes. The other is from the hairdressing room. The empress dowager did not want to see a single fallen hair. According to a late-Qing palace maid, when Li Lianying combed her hair he slipped the fallen strands into his sleeve so she would not see them. That a eunuch could reach such a position is itself a mirror of that court. After Cixi died in 1908 he observed a hundred days of mourning and left the palace. He died of illness in March 1911 and was buried at Enjizhuang, the eunuchs' cemetery outside Fucheng Gate in Beijing. There is also a widely told story about his grave: that it was opened in 1966 and only a skull was found. But those who took part in the clearing recall that the grave already had a robbers' hole and the remains were decayed and incomplete — the matter is still unsettled. Now, how a day of Cixi's went. She rose early — before daylight — washed, had her hair dressed, then went to court and received people. There were two main meals a day: the morning meal around six or seven, the evening meal around midday. A meal laid out a hundred or more dishes, on several tables pushed together, with eunuchs announcing each dish. The rule was "no more than three spoonfuls of any dish" — three mouthfuls and it was taken away. The real problem came after: most of that food was there to be looked at. The afternoon was her time for amusement. She loved opera. In the palace there was the Changyin Pavilion; in the Summer Palace, the Dehe Garden theatre — both three-storey stages. Leading actors such as Tan Xinpei were called in to perform; a good performance brought reward, a mistake brought punishment. She also loved being photographed. In 1903 the two daughters of Yu Geng entered the palace, and their brother Xunling became the palace photographer. Among the photographs that survive is one of her dressed as Guanyin, with eunuchs beside her as guardian figures. She kept dogs — the Summer Palace had a dedicated kennel. She smoked water tobacco from a silver pipe. She kept long nails in nail guards, tended daily. These days were lived on top of a court that was coming apart. To replace a ruler, to hold on to power, to keep an army, to run new policies — all of it takes money. So where did the money come from in those years? The largest single item was the Boxer indemnity. Fixed by the Boxer Protocol of 1901: 450 million haiguan taels, at four percent annual interest, to be repaid over thirty-nine years. Principal and interest together came to about 982 million taels. It was not paid in one sum. It was paid every year — principal plus interest came to more than twenty-one million taels a year. Secured on what? The treaty pledged China's maritime customs, the native customs, and the salt tax. And who handled the money? Five banks — Hongkong and Shanghai, Deutsch-Asiatische, Russo-Chinese, Banque de l' Indochine, and Yokohama Specie together with Citibank, formed a commission to administer it. Where did twenty-one million taels a year come from? It was apportioned among the provinces, and the provinces apportioned it further down. The written names of the levies: land tax, the grain-commuted tax, grain surcharge, deed tax, salt surcharge, the likin transit tax, the consolidated tax. Apportioned far enough down, it landed on those who farmed, those who traded, those who ate salt. Ordinary people gave these additions a name: the "foreign levy" — money paid to foreigners, charged to me. One study counts more than three hundred popular disturbances over refusal to pay such levies in China during the 1900s. A chain ran from a single treaty in Beijing all the way to the tax collector at every village entrance. Whether the court changed its emperor mattered far less to the people at that end of the chain than how much levy they had to pay this year. What did it cost to live in Beijing then? First, how many people were in the city. In the late Qing, the Inner and Outer Cities together held roughly seven to eight hundred thousand. Bannermen made up a substantial share they lived on stipends issued by the court, known as the "iron crop. " A rickshaw puller could earn a few dozen copper cash a day; a vernacular newspaper sold for a few coppers; a policeman drew a monthly wage in silver dollars. That was the ledger of people in the city who had work. The countryside kept a different ledger. After 1900, the extra levy a village carried often equalled several months' grain for a family. The court's accounts were reckoned in the halls; the people's were collected at the village entrance. Same year, same court. Besides the indemnity, the court had its own spending. The " New Policies" after 1901 training a new army, opening schools, building railways, setting up new offices every item was expenditure. The plan called for thirty-six divisions of the new army; what was actually formed was fourteen divisions and twenty brigades, about 190,000 men. When money ran short, it borrowed. In 1910 the court compiled its first national budget. In April 1911 it borrowed ten million pounds from the British, French, German and American banking consortium. On one side, over twenty million taels of indemnity every year; on the other, the cost of soldiering and schooling; and in between, one foreign loan after another. This account had not been balanced by the day the dynasty ended. Amid all these accounts, one item was the exception. The Beijing–Zhangjiakou railway, from Beijing to Zhangjiakou, was begun in 1905 and completed in 1909. Its chief engineer was Zhan Tianyou. The difficulty was around Badaling. The mountains were high and the gradient steep, and trains could not climb it; the engineers laid a " Y"-shaped switchback at Qinglongqiao so trains could reverse up the slope. The Badaling tunnel runs about 1,090 metres. How was it cut? There was no heavy machinery. Workers sank vertical shafts from the ridge down, then drove headings from the shaft in both directions — one working face became four — and that is how they got through more than a kilometre of mountain. Explosives, shovels and handcarts: muscle. The steepest stretch exceeded thirty parts per thousand; an ordinary locomotive could not haul a train up it, so an extra engine was coupled ahead — pulling in front, pushing behind. There is also a much-quoted line: that a foreigner declared the Chinese engineer who could build this line had not yet been born. The saying is often repeated, but no original source has been found; it is given here only as a story. The key figure is the cost: the whole line actually cost some 5.72 million taels, averaging about 34,500 taels per kilometre — among the lowest unit costs of any railway in China at the time. Someone worked out the comparison: one year's Boxer indemnity apportionment, over twenty-one million taels, would have built roughly four Beijing– Zhangjiakou lines. The same money, paying a debt on one side, building a railway on the other. Two faces of the same court. While the court was changing its ruler and paying its debts, society was changing too. On September 2, 1905, the court ordered the examination system abolished. Counting from the Sui and Tang, thirteen hundred years of examinations ended that day. Scholars no longer entered office through the eight-legged essay; they went to new-style schools. A year earlier, in 1904, the court had promulgated the " Guimao school system, " dividing schools nationwide into elementary, middle and higher. The Imperial University in the capital stood at the top. Young people with no school to enter and no wish to stay home went to Japan. In 1907 there were about fifteen thousand Chinese students in Japan. A person's prospects shifted from "which essay do I sit" to "which school, and where to study abroad" — the deepest and quietest change of that decade. Why did the court suddenly want a constitution? The answer lies in someone else's war. In February 1904 Japan and Russia went to war in China's northeast. The fighting was in Liaodong and Fengtian. The Qing government declared itself "neutral" and set aside a stretch of its own territory as a battlefield. Hundreds of thousands of Chinese became refugees on their own land. In May 1905 the Japanese navy destroyed the Russian fleet in the Strait of Tsushima. In September the two countries signed the treaty at Portsmouth, in the United States. Chinese newspapers and officials at the time read the war as a single conclusion: Japan was a constitutional state, Russia an autocracy, and the small constitutional country had beaten the large autocratic one. Whether that conclusion was right is another matter — but it spread fast. In July 1905, Yuan Shikai, governor-general of Zhili, Zhang Zhidong, governor-general of Huguang, and Zhou Fu, governor-general of Liangjiang, jointly memorialized asking the court for a constitution. Six months later the court sent five ministers abroad to study foreign governments. A war fought to its end on someone else's land became the court's answer to "whom should we learn from. " On the political system too, the court moved. In 1905 it sent five ministers abroad to study constitutions. In 1906 it announced "preparation for constitutional government. " In 1908 it promulgated the Outline of the Constitution, setting a nine-year preparatory period, with a parliament planned for 1917. In 1909 the provinces held elections for consultative assemblies — the first elections to a local representative body in Chinese history. But time was not on the court's side. It asked for nine years; others would not wait nine years. Nine years were set for preparation. Only three were had. Back to the city itself. Leshou Hall in the Summer Palace was among the first places to be fitted with electric light. Among the palace women, Consort Zhen was among the earliest to take up photography, and left a number of photographs. The city had vernacular newspapers, photographic studios, and rickshaws on the streets. The other side: bannermen lived on the court's stipends — the "iron crop" — and by the late Qing those stipends went less and less far, so that holding office and mortgaging property existed side by side. Cixi loved opera. The Dehe Garden theatre in the Summer Palace, a three-storey stage, was built for that; performers like Tan Xinpei were summoned to sing at court. Electric light, cameras, newspapers, opera stages the last decade of an old court was also its liveliest. Back to that November. On November 14, 1908, Guangxu died at Hanyuan Hall on Yingtai, aged thirty-eight, in the thirty-fourth year of his reign. The next day, November 15, in the wei hour, Cixi died at Yiluan Hall in Zhongnanhai, aged seventy-four. An emperor who wanted reform but was held for ten years died on an island ringed by water. A woman who had held power for him for forty-seven years died in a hall not far away. Less than a day apart. That coincidence of timing became, over the century since, the most often told part of the story. How did the emperor die? The question has been discussed for a century. There are four main accounts; they are set out here side by side. First, illness. Guangxu was frail and sickly for years, and the palace medical records list a body full of complaints. This account rests on those case records. Second, that Cixi killed him. The reasoning: the two deaths came too close together, and Cixi did not want Guangxu to hold power again after she was gone. Third, that Li Lianying killed him. This appears in some memoirs. Fourth, that Yuan Shikai and Yi Kuang killed him. The reasoning: both had crossed the emperor in the 1898 coup. Each of the four has its own basis and its own sources; none has complete, direct evidence. All four are set out here, and no verdict is offered. The turn came in recent decades. In 1980 archaeologists cleared the underground palace of the Chongling mausoleum in the Western Qing tombs — Guangxu's tomb. His remains were examined then, and no clear sign of poisoning was found. After 2003 a research group on the cause of Guangxu's death took a different approach. Instead of looking only at bone, they tested his hair and the burial garments. In 2008 the group published its conclusion: arsenic levels in Guangxu's hair and clothing were abnormally high, consistent with acute arsenic poisoning. That November the finding was widely reported. The same question: in 1980 they looked at bone, in 2008 at hair. Change the evidence and the answer changes. This is the scientific method — and also an attitude toward history: what counts as settled often depends on what method you look with. On the day before she died, Cixi made one last decision. She made Puyi, son of Prince Chun (Zaifeng), emperor. Puyi was three years old. Zaifeng was made regent, to hold power for the child emperor. A woman who had guarded power for forty-seven years handed the court, at the end, to a three-year-old and a regent. Three years later, that court was gone. But that is the next episode. This one stops inside those two days. This city holds another ending, two hundred and sixty-four years earlier. On March 19, 1644, Li Zicheng's army entered Beijing. It was not yet light. Zhu Youjian, the last Ming emperor the Chongzhen emperor — came out of the Forbidden City and walked onto a mound of earth to the north. In the Ming it was called Coal Hill; today it is Jingshan. Before the manner of his death, what sort of emperor he was. He was among the hardest-working of the Ming emperors. For seventeen years he rose before dawn and was still reading memorials at night; he was frugal, and wore patched clothes. But he was also suspicious and hasty: in seventeen years he went through more than fifty grand secretaries, had a minister of war executed, and put to death Yuan Chonghuan, the commander in Ji and Liao. At that dawn he had the bells rung in the palace to summon the officials to court. The bells rang a long time. No one came. He went back to the inner palace, had Empress Zhou kill herself, and with his own hand slashed his sixteen-year-old daughter Princess Changping and killed the young Princess Zhaoren. Then he and the eunuch Wang Cheng'en went up Coal Hill, and he hanged himself from a tree on the eastern slope. Wang Cheng'en hanged himself from a tree nearby. According to the Ming shi, he left words on the front of his robe to this effect: I have reigned seventeen years, and my ministers have failed me; I have no face to meet my ancestors; I take off my crown and cover my face with my hair; let the rebels do as they will with my body, only do not harm the people. After his death the body was hastily buried in the tomb of Consort Tian. Only after the Qing entered the Pass was he reburied, under the name " Siling" one of the smallest among the thirteen Ming tombs. Jingshan is still there, directly across from the Gate of Divine Prowess of the Palace Museum. Two stelae stand on the hill: one reads " Place where Emperor Sizong of Ming died for his state, " written by Shen Yinmo in 1930; the other is the " Stele for the three-hundredth anniversary, " erected in 1944. The locust tree from which Chongzhen hanged himself was given a name by the early Qing: the " Guilty Locust, " and was chained with an iron chain. The tree on the hill today was planted later. Wanchun Pavilion, the highest point of Jingshan, is the high point of Beijing's central axis — look south from it and you see the whole Forbidden City; look north and you see the Bell and Drum Towers. In 1644 an emperor hanged himself on this hill. In 1908 another emperor died on an island ringed by water. Two hundred and sixty-four years, one city, two different endings. Of the places in this episode, which can still be visited? The Chongling mausoleum, where Guangxu ended up, is in the Western Qing tombs at Yixian in Hebei. Work began in 1909; Guangxu was interred in 1913; it was completed in 1915. It was robbed in 1938, cleared and opened in 1980, and today you can walk down into the underground palace. At Yulantang in the Summer Palace, the bricked-up rear doorway is still there, and visitors can walk right up to it. The Summer Palace was inscribed on the World Heritage List in 1998. The Well of Consort Zhen is in the Palace Museum — the well visitors walk past. The consorts' tombs beside Chongling are where Zhen was later reburied. The Chongling underground palace is open today; you can go down the stone steps and see the stone doors and the vaulted ceiling. The Hall of Mental Cultivation in the Palace Museum, where Guangxu worked and lived during the years he held power, is open to visitors. Yiluan Hall in Zhongnanhai, where Cixi spent her last days, was burned by the Eight-Nation Alliance in 1900 and later rebuilt; it stands in a government compound and is not open to the public. Yingtai, also in Zhongnanhai, is likewise closed it lies inside the government compound and can only be seen in old photographs. Of Enjizhuang, the eunuchs' cemetery, very little survives; some rubbings of epitaphs remain. Jingshan is open, and you can climb it. It is directly across from the north gate of the Palace Museum. Back to the main line. An emperor held for ten years, and a dowager empress who held power for forty-seven years, died in the same city less than a day apart. It was not that the court never thought of replacing him. In 1900 they had even drafted the new reign name, and still it did not happen. Why could they not? The title could not be gotten around; a successor could not be made to stand; outsiders would not recognize it; and the guns were not in their hands. In the end they handed this court to a three-year-old and a regent. Three years later, the court was gone. That day is the next episode. The full script of this film is at sylogs.com. --- Source: sylogs.com